Comparison of the Pigulevskaya and MarcBloch historiography method on the system of feudalism

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 alzahra university

2 Ghazvin

Abstract

This article to the comparative study of the historiography method Pigulevskaya Famous writer Russian with Marc Bloch, of the pioneers of the French Annales School of about system of the feudalism. Marc Bloch examined Feudalism in Europe, but Pigulevskaya with a more Marxist viewpoint, noticed the Orient, especially Iran. The question therefore arises as to why Pigulevskaya used the word "feudal" in spite of its difference with the economic structure of Iran? It is hypothesized that she like Marxists with a holistic view her considered the stage of evolution and linear trajectory of Marx's thought to be everywhere in the world, including Iran, and thus generalized it against the Annales School. This paper uses the method of research in historiography description and analysis based examines the dimensions and angles of the subject. Findings show, Marc Bloch, in view of the prevailing thinking over the Annales School, has used the structure and all the evidence in explaining an event, but Pigulevskayaby following Soviet historians, has considered the same economic and Marxist tought infrastructure.

Keywords


- Azhand, Yaqub. (1388). Historiography in Iran, Ch2, Tehran, Gostareh.
- A. Couric, James. (1380). The Early Middle Ages, translated by Mehdi Khatiqkhah, Tehran, Phoenix.
- Edwards, Paul. (1375). Philosophy of history (collection of articles from the encyclopedia of philosophy), translated by Behzad Saleki, Tehran, Research Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies.
- Stanford, Michael. (2013). An introduction to the history of research, translated by Masoud Sadeghi, Ch7, Tehran, Imam Sadegh University (AS) and Samt.
- Stoyanovich, Trayan. (1386). Historical Method or Anal Paradigm, translated by Nasrin Jahangard, Tehran, Space Scientific and Cultural Institute.
- Scotchpole, Teda. (2012). Insight and method of historical sociology, translated by Hashem Aghajari, Ch2, Tehran, Center.
- Burke, Peter. (1381). History and social theory, translated by Gholamreza Jamshidiha, Tehran, Tehran University Press.
- Brahmand, Gholamreza. (2007). A reflection on the nature of the Mazdakian movement, Moskvieh magazine, year 3, number 10.
- Bloch, Mark. (1363). Feudal society, translated by Behzad Bashi, 2 volumes, Tehran, Aghaz.
- Petroshevski, A.P. (1357). Agriculture and land relations in Iran during the Mughal era, translated by Karim Keshavarz, Vol. 1, Tehran, Nile.
- (1344). Agriculture and Agrarian Relations in Iran during the Mughal Era, translated by Karim Keshavarz, Vol. 2, Tehran, Institute of Social Studies and Research, University of Tehran.
- Pigoloskaya, N.V. (and others). (1353). History of Iran from ancient times to the end of the 18th century AD, translated by Karim Keshavarz, Ch3, Tehran, Payam.
- (1372). Arabs around the borders of Eastern Rome and Iran in the 4th and 6th centuries AD, translated by Inayat Elah Reza, Tehran, Institute of Cultural Studies and Research (Research Institute).
- (1387). Cities of Iran in the time of Parthians and Sasanians, translated by Inayat Elah Reza, 4th year, Tehran, scientific and cultural.
- Dulandlen, Charles. (2008). World history, translated by Ahmad Bahmanesh, Vol. 1, Tehran University Press.
- Zarin Koob, Rozbeh and Suleimanzadeh, Alireza. (2012). Studying the period of the elementary communal system in the history of Iranian society from the perspective of Soviet Iranologists, Iranology Research Journal, year 3, number 2.
- Sedki, Nasser. (2011). A reflection on the Marxist sociological approach to Iranian history, Journal of Historical Sciences Research, Volume 4, Number 1.
- (2014). On theoretical issues about the construction and executive function of the government in the history of Iran, Historical Sociology Journal, Volume 7, Number 1.
- Katouzian, Mohammad Ali Homayoun. (1372). Political economy of Iran (from constitutionalism to the end of the Pahlavi dynasty), translated by Mohammad Reza Nafisi and Kambiz Azizi, Ch2, Tehran, Center.
- Karimi, Behzad. (1389). Anal History School, Islamic History and Civilization Journal, Year 6, Number 11.
- Nowzari, Hossein Ali. (1378). Historiography or School of Authenticity of History, Iranian Contemporary History Journal, Year 3, Number 9.
- Vago, Stefan. (1373). An introduction to theories and models of social changes, translated by Ahmed Reza Gharavizad, Qom, Jihad University Publications.
- Hamilton, Gary J. and Randall (and others). (2015). Historiography and Historical Sociology, translated by Hashim Aghajari, Ch3, Tehran, Kavir.
- Yari, Yasman. (2014). The impact of structuralism of the first and second generation of historians of the Anal School, Tarikh Islam in the mirror of research, year 11, number 1.